Tuesday, 19 October 2010

Privilege - A Defence Against Popes and Pussycats


Privilege is essentially exemption from the law, and as great as that sounds, unfortunately there are rules to abide by. Absolute privilege (AP) is granted to Members of Parliament whenever they are in session at the House of Commons. This allows MPs to speak freely without any fear of libel action against them from anyone they may slander or defame by doing so. This can be especially juicy as it does not matter if  it is malicious. If they really wanted to they could forget politics and have a slagging match in which they call each other Martian-Yeti Gigolos (I hope I didn’t just discriminate against female MPs). Of course, the odds on that happening are pretty slim, yet we will stand ready, just in case.

There seems to be a bone of contention between McNae’s and the Privilege Notes on the website, as McNae‘s claims that under some circumstances journalists are afforded AP. This is contradicted by the course notes. As a compromise I’ll simply write what the book says on the subject, then carry on as if nothing has happened (hopefully I’ll be corrected one way or the other).

Journalists are permitted absolute privilege when reporting court cases or the proceedings of certain types of tribunals. Journalists are only granted absolute privilege if the material they publish is: Fair, Accurate and published contemporaneously (it’s a posh word for quickly). For a report to be fair and accurate it needs:
  • A summary of both sides.
  • No substantial inaccuracies (in this case, inaccuracies that create a false or misleading impression).
  • To be unbiased.
For a report to be contemporaneous means it must be published as soon as possible so that would be the next possible publication. If the report is not published as quickly as possible it may still enjoy qualified privilege if it fits the statutes required under common law.

Qualified privilege (QP) is a defence that can be used in situations where it is considered important that the facts should be freely known to the public. Circumstances where this defence can be used include court cases, council meetings and police statements. The requirements to use qualified privilege differ from absolute privilege in that motives play a key part in the former as there can be no evidence of malicious intent. General requirements for qualified privilege are that the report must be:
  • Fair, accurate, and published without malice.
  • Of public concern/be of benefit to the public.
It is important to note that there is no qualified privilege for a report of defamatory statements made after a case or meeting when people involved are asked to expand on statements made during the proceedings.

QP in common law is formed by judges and convention as opposed to statute. Common law QP applies to certain circumstances where potentially defamatory statements are protected for “the common convenience and welfare of society”. One circumstance where a person may make a defamatory statement in a moral, legal, or social duty to another who has a vested interest in receiving it, would be in the case of someone asking for a reference from a past employer, or lecturer. The lecturer would have to tell the truth and as long as it is not malicious, he cannot be sued for libel over the reference.

A highly important and influential case involving Albert Reynolds vs. Sunday Times further defined QP protection outside of a court reporting situation. Reynolds, the then Prime Minister of Ireland was reported by the Sunday Times to have tried to (and lied about) cover up a child abuse scandal in the Catholic church (A similar case has been ongoing for a while involving the Pope when he was still Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger). Reynolds sued for defamation and the newspaper said that while it believed it to be true, there was no evidence. This could have been a very sticky situation, however, on reaching the higher courts, the judges thought the paper had had a duty to publish the allegations. this was due to a relevance to public interest and simply that they weren't unreasonable. Lord Nicholls, the Judge in the appeal stage of the case, decided that the media needed more protection so that they could continue to report stories in the name of the public interest. He set out a list of 10 points that will provide QP if covered in writing such a report. I wont write these out as will no doubt take up a lot of space, however they can be found in the qualified privilege course notes.

It must be noted that the Reynolds defence is not an automatic protection as long as you make a token gesture for any of the points. An important case involving George Galloway showcased this point. The Daily Telegraph made serious defamatory statements against George Galloway for which there was no defence of justification or fair comment. The Telegraph claimed it had documents found by one of its reporters that suggested Galloway was in the pay of Saddam Hussein. It further claimed that it had a duty to publish the allegations even if they were untrue. The paper lost the case because it failed the 10 points of the Reynolds defence. Apart from a quick call to Galloway, they did not make any real attempt to put the allegations to him and recieve comment from him reagrding the truth of them. The Telegraph were ordered to pay £150,000 in damages as well as around £1.2 million in costs.

If there's anything I've gleaned from this, it's that as long as you are very diligent and careful, without sacrificing haste, you should be well defended in terms of Privilege. That and not to mess with George Galloway. He's a meaner pussycat than Big Brother would have had me believe.

Sunday, 17 October 2010

John Locke: Life, Liberty and (if you're American) the Pursuit of Happiness

Our third HCJ lecture focused mainly on John Locke’s ‘Essay Concerning Human Understanding’ and his thoughts on Social Contracts. This was also linked with Hobbes and his work ‘Leviathan’, both of which were written following the aftermath of the English civil war, as well as being influenced by this period of political upheaval. However both doctrines disagree with each other more often than they are in accord.

Locke and Hobbes both wanted the monarchy to be rid of it’s ‘mystical quality’, meaning that Kings should stop claiming to have divine power and authority. Locke attacks this point, especially in reference to Sir Robert Filmer, whose work ‘Patriarcha’ deals with the hereditary principle that Adam was given Kingly authority by God, and therefore all subsequent monarchs are heirs to Adam’s Authority. Locke tore Filmer’s arguments apart following simple logical reasoning that if this hereditary power were so important, it would make no difference to be born male or female (but most monarchies are heavily misogynistic). Not to mention that surely Adam would only have one true heir, and therefore all other kings are usurpers. From this basis Locke decides that a system of  hereditary leadership is unjust and a people should be given the ability to choose who is to lead them.

Both men talk about a ‘State of Nature’ which could have existed before any form of government. Hobbes theorised that in such a world, people would act on their passions, would have no inhibitions, and would have a right to everything and anything he wanted. This would lead to wars following an every man for himself policy. He claim life in that time would be
“Solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short”. Therefore, the people would choose to give absolute power to a leader who would hold their natural rights for the sake of protection. Locke opposes this argument, saying that exchanging all rights for personal safety with an absolute ruler will not work in the long run. He has a very different impression of this State of Nature: Everyone has natural freedom, but will follow natural laws governed by a set of morals known by everyone intuitively as they are “interwoven in the constitution of the human mind”. He goes on to state that these morals would be discovered by human reason, but were originally given by God (He is lovely isn’t he, that God). Not only does reason give us moral guidelines however, oh no, Locke states that there is nothing in our brain, no knowledge or ideas, that don’t come from experience. This flies directly against Cartesian thinking and no doubt caused a ruckus in their camp. But then when you present any kind of dogmatic thinking with other reasoning, you will no doubt receive a backlash of some kind.

As part of Locke’s Social Contract he maintained that civil government is the result of a contract and should be in no way hindered by any divine authority. The difference in Locke’s Contract compared to others (especially Hobbes, who claimed that once established, the government had complete authority to the point of tyranny, and the people had no right to rebellion) is that the sovereign was party to the contract and can be rightly resisted if it fails to keep its part of the bargain. Parallel to this is the natural right of every man to revolt against a government that ceases to respect the law.

A subject which Locke seems to be obsessed with is the concept of property. He claims that the formation of all governments was to protect the property of all within it. One of his main tenets is that every man has a right to Life, Liberty, and Property (on the assumption that the second two don’t impeach on another’s). The American constitution quotes this when they say that every man has the right to Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness. His proposed concept of Government is one made by consent from the majority of people populating it, and limited by laws (that effect everyone), and powers used mainly for the protection of property. This is taken to such an extent that he presents an example of a soldier in an army. If this soldier breaks any rules or oaths required of him, he may be disciplined . But not by the taking of his property. Locke considers that to be a terrible act. He may however be punished in so far as his body may be punished, by flogging for example. I’m sure that would certainly be the much preferred choice.

Locke’s theories on Human Understanding are a bold innovation compared to pretty much every philosopher since Plato, as he uses empiricist theory to state that there is no such thing as innate ideas, and all knowledge comes from sensation, and the perception of the operation of the mind. Locke’s empiricist teachings directly contradict those of Plato, down to and including Descartes and his contemporary Leibniz. He was wholly against ‘Innate Ideas’ as described by Plato and Descartes, which  he discusses in great detail in the first book of his Essay Concerning Human Understanding. He claims that rather than giving us a vague blueprint; God gave us the ability to discover knowledge and morality through reasoning.

It is interesting to note that Locke, a believer in God (though it is difficult to name his exact religion), was of the opinion that religion should never mix with politics. One could say that this is obvious concerning his thoughts on hereditary divinity, and perhaps he simply saw the effect religion can have on an otherwise sensible constitution of government. I certainly wonder what he would think of the situation in America, where it’s practically anathema to admit to being an atheist, and in some cases to being anything other than Christian. I think that Locke simply saw how chaotic things can become when you mix fundamentalism with power. To quote Douglas Adams:
“Anyone who is capable of getting themselves into a position of power should on no account be allowed to do the job”.
I'm not 100% sure of how relevant that is but I have put up 7 posts and haven't quoted Adams in any of them, so I think I owe him a shout out.

Thursday, 14 October 2010

WINOL Bulletin Criticism

After Watching the latest WINOL bulletin in my first instance of a critically minded journalist peer. I think that in general, it is of very high quality, in terms of editing, presentation, and professionalism. This is not to say that it was flawless however. The first instance of what I considered of poor quality, was the sound of the section filmed in the multimedia centre, discussing pass cards for international students' entry into clubs. Of course, this could be an equipment related issue, in which case this may be something the media department should look into as it spoils the flow of dialogue.

I was very impressed by the performance of the presenters who, apart from some minor slip-ups, were very eloquent and on a par with many professional anchors. That said, the in-field reporters could have been a touch more enthusiastic, especially in the case of one of the sport reporters. If I'm not mistaken, the roles of the WINOL team are continually rotated so as to maximise the experience in different aspects of Broadcast journalism. However, if you happen to be given a role is not necessarily your favourite, you should try and at least make a pretense of not being bored with the whole thing.

In the case of the stories covered in the bulletin, the first two stories were well considered in that they directly affected the target audience: Students. While the first was more directed to international students, rather than the main populace, the second concerned almost everyone attending or soon-to-be attending university. In that respect I think they could have been reversed so as to provide a better hook to non- internationals who could well stop watching if the initial piece doesn't affect them. The Housing and Queen stories were les important in my opinion and were therefore well placed in the midsection. The final story concerning the BJTC award was very well presented and all of the footage piqued my interest (clap clap, by the way), with any luck I'll be able to do the same in a year or two.

A major mistake for which I believe the editor took a lot of flak, was a spelling mistake in the score sheet during the sports section, misspelling some of the names of sports teams. You wouldn't expect such schoolboy mistakes from what is otherwise a very competent piece of journalsm.

All in all I was very impressed with the slick editing (except for one instance during an interview within the tuition fee story, where it seems as though someone was cut off midsentence) and very proffesional appearance of what I would call a top-notch broadcast

Tuesday, 12 October 2010

The Simple Sword of Truth, and the Trusty Barge Pole of Cowardice

Defamation is perhaps one of the most worrying things a journalist can confront. Usually encountered while court reporting (but by no means limited to), a claim of defamation means an accuser thinks that something published concerning them has damaged their reputation and lowered right-minded peoples opinion of them. In many cases, a defamatory statement will expose the subject to hatred, ridicule and contempt from their peers, often resulting in Libel action. You can get an idea of how journalists view being presented with a defamation charge, in that there is actually a name for the feeling you get when considering even a genuine, unbiased story on a person or group that is particularly litigious: The 'Chilling Effect'. For example, the Church of Scientology has filed dozens upon dozens (perhaps even hundreds) of lawsuits, funded by their enormous wealth and influence. Here is a policy letter written by L. Ron Hubbard (the founder of the Church of Scientology), distributed in early 1966:

This is correct procedure:
  1. Spot who is attacking us.
  2. Start investigating them promptly for FELONIES or worse using own professionals, not outside agencies.
  3. Double curve our reply by saying we welcome an investigation of them.
  4. Start feeding lurid, blood sex crime actual evidence on the attackers to the press.
Don't ever tamely submit to an investigation of us. Make it rough, rough on attackers all the way.

Against such a code of conduct, I don't blame people for getting the willies.

Fear not however, we aren't doomed to the dole queue just yet. Journalists are awarded certain defences, provided that they follow a certain code of conduct. The first of these defences is Justification, or to put it simply, Truth. If the reporter can present evidence showing that the published matter in question is in fact true, then this provides complete protection against any libel action. A very famous example of justification at work was that of Conservative cabinet minister Jonathon Aitken who filed Libel actions against The Guardian for reporting that his bill for the Ritz hotel in Paris was paid for by an Arab associate, in direct breach of ministerial guidelines. He even resigned from his post stating that he would:
 "Fight to cut out the cancer of bent and twisted journalism in our country with the simple sword of truth and the trusty shield of British fair play". 
After four years of investigations and court trials, evidence was found that proved that Aitken had been lying all along, and that he had been willing to have his daughter lie under oath to protect him, saying that it was his wife Lolicia Aitken who had paid for his hotel stay, when it was in fact found that she had been in Switzerland at the time and it would have been impossible for her to have done so. Aitken was faced with legal costs of £2 million and an 18 month prison sentence (of which he served 7) for committing perjury and perverting the course of justice.

While the Aitken case is a fantastic example of justification at its best, they aren't all quite as interesting. Another defence afforded to journalists is Privilege. This gives protection to publish potentially damaging material in accordance with the principle that justice must be seen to be done. As journalist are the eyes and ears of the public, they are allowed to report things that could be defamatory, as long as it is considered in the public interest to do so. Reports may only hold privilege if they are fair and accurate, otherwise you may well find out just how deep the rabbit-hole goes.

The last main defence of defamation is known as Fair Comment. This is essentially exactly what it says on the tin. Such a comment may be published as long as it is: the honestly held opinion of the writer; recognisable as opinion (not presented as fact); based on provably true facts; linked to theprovably true facts, in the same publishing (unless so well known as to make it unnecessary); on a subject that is a matter of public interest. On the plus side it doesn't have to be 'fair' (I know, the name confused me too), a judge/ jury does not have to agree with it to rule it fair comment, as long as it is honest opinion - in other words, not malicious - then we're home free.

The 'Bane and Antidote' defense was also discussed, which is where One would write something negative, followed by something appealing to kiss it all better. However, as far as I can make out, this is very dodgy ground to be used as a defence for defamation, so I would personally not touch it with the preverbial barge pole, could it be avoided.

Monday, 11 October 2010

Law n' Order Laid Out

Following the second Law lecture, I found my views on how journalists affect the law, and how the law affects journalists weren't quite up to scratch. While I was aware that newspapers and other media outlets had to be very careful as to what they published, providing they didn't want to be sued. I was not aware of how precise and clear-cut the rules are concerning court reporting, and reporting in general and how very careful Journalists have to be.

After a brief outline of how courts are established i.e. a judge, 12 members of the jury, barristers representing each side etc. (this being, let's say, a hypothetical Crown Court) We became enlightened to the (many) different codes and laws concerning court proceedings, and Court reporting. One of the most basic, and yet most important fundamentals to all cases, is the 'Presumption of Innocence'. This can be recognised mostly by the fact that someone should never have to prove their innocence, only that the prosecuting party has to prove their guilt. In this respect, especially in those involving juries, it is critical that this is not breached, as it can result in prejudice (influencing a juries decision). This applies to journalists in that, if they report on a defendant as having committed the offence, rather than saying, they are accused of having committed the offence. They are implying guilt on said defendant, which could sway a jury's decision. If a reporter or newspaper is found to have done this, they are in danger of 'Contempt of Court' for which there is no defense. An individual found to have contempt of court could be faced with up to a £40,000 fine, or a 6 month sentence.

Providing however, that any reporting is unbiased, fair, and above-all, accurate.Journalists are granted Qualified Privilege meaning they are exempt from any Libel law action. This does not mean they can simply make it up as they go along (although that would be a hell of an easy job) for that would be Malice: The telling of a lie (whether you believe it to be true makes no difference, as that shows negligence on behalf of the reporter).

Despite whatever apparent limitations on court reporting however, Journalists - in the case of court reporting - are the eyes and ears of the public. Journalists are there to make sure that the law is carried out in full. We help to confirm one of the basic legal principles, 'Justice must be seen to be done'.
Is it just me who thinks that sounds a touch Machiavellian?

Friday, 1 October 2010

The Laws of the Great and the Good, and the not so good.


After having read the first chapter of ‘McNae’s’ and watching our first Law lecture, I would have to admit certain passages caught my attention. Now don’t get me wrong, but reading law in a book is never going to be thrilling. However, I found that once given examples of these codes, it allows you to see what they actually lead to. Or prevent, given the circumstances. The laws relating to Human Rights in particular caught my eye. I had never before connected corruption and political violence in Third World countries to the lack of a Free Press. Now that it’s been pointed out, I can see the impact that Investigative Journalists can have on society by exposing these wrongdoings. It makes one wonder what would be dug up should a Free Press ever be established in, say North Korea. It certainly helps to explain how these dictatorships manage to stay in power so easily. As opposed to the petty fraud of our own ‘Higher-ups’ who can barely sneeze without appearing on the cover of ‘The Sun‘. But then you can’t compare a madman in control of a country on the brink, to a bit of on-the-side moat cleaning, or a little free porn.

I was also quite interested in the court system of the UK, learning about the differences between the Civil and Criminal courts. I wasn’t aware of the court-specific jargon used in each: Found guilty against being ‘held liable’; Only using the term ‘sentence’ in criminal courts etc. I had also never thought much about appeals, I had assumed that if a defendant appealed a decision, the case would be repeated with a new jury and judge. This seemed logical to me as it helps to eliminate the chances of any kind of accidental ruling (looking back I can see how that sounds stupid, but in fairness I’ve not had much experience in these matters till now). In a sense the appeals moving up a court, does introduce a new ‘audience’ and as it moves up, the standard of conduct would be expected to rise in tangent. Therefore, if you were innocent and had been convicted, new evidence would be much more likely to be found or re-examined. It could definitely prove to be interesting to have the number 2 Crown Court in the country here in Winchester. Never know, we could get lucky.

I myself could be getting some first-hand experience of the UK’s court system as I’m currently engaged in a GBH case against a bouncer, so I’ll certainly be taking notes if it comes to that.

I welcome any and all criticism on this post, as with a constitutional code as ever-changing and complicated (to me) as ours, I’m certain I’ll have misunderstood something along the line.

Thanks for bearing with me.

Thursday, 30 September 2010

On the Renaissance and Remarkable Men.

After this first in-depth lecture on the Renaissance, I can't help but picture it stepping out of what can be safely described as a quagmire of ignorance. Free Thought finds it's feet (metaphorically) shackled by the dogged stubbornness of the Church and it's vehement control of ideas that dare to step outside the iron word of the Bible and it's accompanying philosophies. The rediscovery of ancient Greek writings and dialogues breathe new life into this stagnation and free thought as hasn't been known for 1000 odd years. Renaissance Italy finds itself redeveloping in style of these "new" Hellenistic teachings. A new age had begun and people seemed desperate to have a part. Perhaps the most influential of these philosophers was Plato, best known for his 'Theory of Forms' which states that the world in which we live is but a crude copy of a perfect world. To demonstrate this simply, I could say "this is a window. But somewhere there is a better window, and somewhere else is a perfect window". Plato demonstrates his theory using his 'Cave' analogy, in which, men are trapped in a cave, whilst outside is a wondrous world. However all the men can see are the pale shadows of this world falling on the cave walls. He did go further in describing his Forms using a straight line and a circle.  He says that no one has ever seen a perfect circle, or a perfect line (he must be right about this as no matter how small you make the building blocks, there will be some smaller still that we can't see), and yet everybody knows what a circle and a line are. He claims that this knowledge or blueprint that we innately have, is evidence that somewhere, these fabled Forms exist.

Another famous Greek philosopher was Aristotle, Plato's student. Aristotle is well known for (among many other things) his use of logic through deductive reasoning or 'Analytics' as he called it. Using both inductive and deductive logic (unlike Plato who used only deductive logic). I think it can be argued that most, if not all modern scientific study follows Aristotle's Example in using inductive reasoning, as we have come to the conclusion that pretty much everything we know could be wrong. Therefore inductive reasoning is less potentially embarrassing for all concerned. Both Plato and Aristotle are depicted in Raphael's 'School of Athens' showing their philosophical differences, Plato gestures toward the heavens, Demonstrating his confidence in the Forms. While Aristotle indicates the Earth, communicating belief in his theories through empirical evidence and a solid trust in his senses.

It seems that whenever the renaissance is mentioned, people have this image in their mind of a glorious shining beacon of learning  and enlightenment. This is fairly accurate, in it's way. Art took on a new depth and beauty as opposed to the stark austerity of the Dark Ages preceding it. Not to mention great names such as Leonardo Da Vinci, Michelangelo, and Raphael rising to become masters of Renaissance art. Considering all of this refinement and prosperity of learning. I was very surprised to learn about the various undercurrents running throughout Italy which seem to show them all to be morally bankrupt swine. Albeit cunning swine. It seems as though, if they weren't all constantly engaging in civil war; Then they were going to an audience with the Pope, afraid to drink the wine in case it were poisoned. Now, don't get me wrong I'm not exactly an advocate of Christianity (nor of religion in general) but still, the Pope! Christ knows how these guys felt about so much as leaving the house without wearing a full suit of armour! Bertrand Russell does make a point of highlighting Pope Alexander VI, along with his son Caesor Borgia (who I'll mention later concerning Machiavelli) saying of the two:
"The wickedness off these two men soon became legendary, and it is difficult to disentangle truth from falsehood as regards to the innumerable murders of which they are accused"
The fact that this can be said about two men, one of which would be held up as an example of piety and of representing the highest orders of the Church, Holding the keys to Heaven no less! Says something about the sort of times in which they lived. A keen sense of politics and an ability to manipulate, would have been crucial to success. and in this respect we move on to the works of Niccolò Machiavelli.

Niccolò Machiavelli 1467 - 1527 was a very clever man, if not exactly the most ethical. He was a master of political science and wrote the first (I believe) 'How To' guide for rulers. More specifically, he wrote it as a peace-offering to the Medici family, the current rulers of Florence, who he had angered by serving another ruler. He gathered many of his frames of reference for his book 'The Prince' through his own first-hand experience of the successes and failures of various nobles of the times. Perhaps most notably Savonarola, who seems a particularly dour person to be around, especially considering the general Renaissance brightness and artfulness. After burning everything he considered gaudy or creative (or fun) in his infamous 'Burning of the Vanities' and generally making the lives of everyone in Florence a misery he was torn apart and burnt on a cross for heresy among other crimes, as demanded by Pope Alexander VI (and we know how much of a saint he was). After witnessing this execution, Machiavelli put together one of his most important statements "all armed prophets have conquered and unarmed prophets have come to grief”. This, along with his other works, have since changed the way in which people went about looking for and seizing power. Many critics of Machiavelli claim he was amoral, even evil. I disagree. I see him as the ultimate pragmatist. A man who saw that while certain methods were not the most ethical, they did the job they were meant for. And they did it well. He uses the example of Caesar Borgia (mentioned earlier) as one of the greatest 'Princes' of the time. he portrayed him as a man who saw what was needed, and how to do it so that it least affected himself negatively. He knew that cruelty is inevitable, and while Borgia was indeed cruel Machiavelli wrote that "his harsh measures restored order to the Romagna, unifying it and rendering it peaceful and loyal". He continues this by pointing out that it is always preferable to be cruel to the few, so that you wont have to be cruel to many. Otherwise you will be hated by your people and that is one of the worst things for a ruler to have happen "My view it that it is desirable to be both loved and feared; but it is difficult to achieve both and, if one of them has to be lacking, it is much safer to be feared than loved.". Machiavelli wrote many other worthy books of note, although only one of the was published during his lifetime: 'The Art of War'. This was probably because many of his books would have gotten him killed, had they been published while he was alive.
Machiavelli died in 1527, the same year as the sack of Rome. Some people also regard it as the death of the Renaissance. He was buried with the inscription "TANTO NOMINI NULLUM PAR ELOGIUM", possibly translated as "So great a name has no adequate praise".

The final part of the lecture that I will be covering that of René Descartes. Now, in my previous post, I made a rather frank appraisal of Descartes 'Cogito' saying that it was simplistic, that it was too easy to say that we're here because we are. However, after a more detailed look at his work I have decided that I need to reassess my thinking. Here goes, beginning at the beginning.

Descartes was born post-Renaissance into the Age of Reason, in fact, one could make the argument that it was he that began it. He is the founder of Cartesian Doubt. This, as a mainstay for his other arguments demands drawing conclusions only from what you can and cannot doubt. For example, you cannot doubt (in his mind) the truths of mathematics or mechanical science. However, before he could believe in these things. He had to believe in himself. And now we come to his deductive reasoning. He used doubt to decide what things around him he could believe were true i.e. Can I doubt that I am in this room? Yes, because it could be a dream. And so forth until he came to the last part of himself he may be able to doubt. Can I doubt I am thinking? No, because the fact that I can think of doubting it, means that I'm thinking "Cogito ergo sum", "I think, therefore I am". Here was where I had a problem, but my problem was that by itself  "I think, therefore I am" means nothing. But with all the background I realised, that was not his philosophy. 'Cogito ergo sum' was Square One of his philosophy. Before he had that established, he could do nothing. And so from his first square he decided that if he existed, God must exist, and he must be a benevolent God, and therefore he can trust himself because God - being good - would not mislead him. If he can trust himself, then everything else begins to fall into place as according to his own reasoning. I have to say that I'm still not 100% on this, as it is crucially linked to a belief in God, which I lack. However it is extremely well thought out, and very logical (which I approve of) and he uses his system to demonstrate a number of different suppositions in support of Rationalism, and leading into Idealism in which his work becomes a springboard for later philosophers such as Kant and Hegel.

Looking back I'm beginning to think i should have split this in half. I seem to have gotten very enthusiastic once I got to Machiavelli and Descartes, people I can actually wrap my head around. Nonetheless you're stuck with it now, I'm off to make an awful attempt at some shorthand.